Science News logo

Science Service logo

Double Trees: City trees grow bigger than country cousins

Susan Milius

A popular tree grows twice as well in the New York metropolitan sprawl as in rural New York State, according to a new test.


CITY HEIGHTS. Plant ecologist Jillian Gregg stands between cottonwood clones grown in urban sites in the New York metropolitan area (left) and rural sites (right).

Cornell Univ.

Clones of an Eastern cottonwood (Populus deltoides) in the Bronx and other city spots grew to double the biomass of clones planted outside small towns upstate or on Long Island, says Jillian Gregg, now of the Environmental Protection Agency's western-ecology division in Corvallis, Ore.

The growth gap comes from ozone damage, she and her New York colleagues report. Ozone chemists have known that concentrations may spike skyscraper high in city air, but during a full 24 hours, rural trees actually get a higher cumulative ozone exposure from urban pollution that blows in and lingers. A series of new experiments now shows that this hang-around ozone is the overwhelming factor in tree growth, the researchers say in the July 10 Nature.

"This study has profound importance in showing us most vividly that rural areas pay the price for [urban] pollution," says Stephen P. Long of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. "This work should be a wake-up call," he adds.

Earlier studies had fingered car fumes, heavy metals in soils, and other cityscape menaces to plant life. Yet some urban quirks, such as extra warmth and increased concentrations of carbon dioxide, may boost plant growth.

To see the net effect of these opposing factors, Gregg and her colleagues planted genetically identical cottonwood saplings in farmland outside the small towns of Millbrook, Riverhead, and Upton and in four metropolitan sites. The study is "definitely the first of its kind in considering multiple factors," she says.

For 3 years, the team set out trees in July and harvested them in September. In similar light conditions, the city trees grew faster than the rural ones. Rainfall didn't differ significantly, nor did pest damage.

The boost didn't come from the soil, she concluded. City trees consistently outpaced country trees, even when both were grown in soil that she had brought from the other location. Experiments in growth chambers showed that the benefit didn't come from carbon dioxide or temperature differences.

Since she couldn't explain how the city accelerates tree growth, Gregg says, she searched for plant inhibitors in the country. Of the 18 pollutants she checked, ozone was the only one significantly higher at her rural sites, 28 parts per billion versus 16 ppb in town. That rural dose is typical in the Northeast, she says. When she compared cottonwood growth in open-topped chambers supplied with flows of ozone at a test facility, she found big differences in growth from different ozone abundances.

"We all think of urban areas, with high automobile densities, as sites of great pollution," says Eva Pell of Pennsylvania State University in State College. However, she points out, ozone is famously reactive, and the abundance of other urban pollutants, including nitric oxide, may scrub ozone out of city air.

"That doesn't mean city air is cleaner. It just means it has less ozone—and that's an important distinction," says David Grantz, an air-quality specialist at the University of California's Kearney Agricultural Center in Parlier.

Cottonwood trees may not suffer much from other pollutants such as particulates. However, Grantz says, a "hot area of research" now shows that people certainly do.



Gregg, J.W., C.G. Jones, and T.E. Dawson. 2003. Urbanization effects on tree growth in the vicinity of New York City. Nature 424(July 10):183–187. Abstract.

Further Readings:

Gorman, J. 2001. Ozone flares with fireworks festivities. Science News 159(June 30):404. Available at Science News.

Monastersky, R. 1999. China's air pollution chokes crop growth. Science News 155(March 27):197. Available at Science News.

Raloff, J. 2000. U.S. smog limit permits subtle lung damage. Science News 157(May 13):308. Available at Science News.


Jillian W. Gregg
US EPA - Western Ecology Division
200 SW 35th Street
Corvallis, OR 97333

Stephen P. Long
University of Illinois
Departments of Crop Sciences and Plant Biology
190 Edward R. Madigan Laboratory
1201 West Gregory Drive
Urbana, IL 61801-3838

Eva J. Pell
Pennsylvania State University
304 Old Main
University Park, PA 16802

David Grantz
Air Pollution Research Center
Department of Botany and Plant Sciences
Kearney Agricultural Center
9240 South Riverbend Avenue
Parlier, CA 93648

From Science News, Volume 164, No. 2, July 12, 2003, p. 20.