Science News logo

Science Service logo


Venting Concerns
Exploring and protecting deep-sea communities

Janet Raloff

Researchers cruising the South Pacific between Tonga and Fiji study huge snails that, aided by an abundance of bacteria housed in their gills, feed off plumes of metal-rich compounds at active hydrothermal vents. Scientists working off the California coast use chemical-sniffing probes, robotically driven subs, and seafloor-tethered temperature sensors to watch flows of lava pave over a once-thriving ecosystem at hydrothermal vents several kilometers below the ocean's surface. And in waters off Papua New Guinea, a mining company analyzes metal deposits around inactive, underwater volcanoes that contain, on average, 10 times as much copper as typical ores on land do.

photo

Tubeworms offer a backdrop to a lanky fish and crabs at a hydrothermal vent site 2,500 meters below the sea surface in the eastern Pacific Ocean. Vent scientists have developed a code of conduct for their research practices so they won't harm deep-sea ecosystems.

Courtesy of Richard A. Lutz, Rutgers University

These studies exemplify the breadth of research under way at one of Earth's last great frontiers, the geologically active ocean bottom. Sites include hydrothermal vents on the 65,000-km-long ridge that meanders through all the world's oceans and at deeply submerged volcanoes in the tropical west Pacific. Only 35 years ago, scientists didn't know that geologically active sites existed underwater. Now, they have direct evidence of some 300 such spots and suspect that another 700 or so await discovery. The researchers are also uncovering signs of past geological activity at many sites.

As recently as 1990, the cost and difficulty of getting to the few then-recognized sites limited visits by scientists. Today, however, submerged volcanoes and other deep hydrothermal vents have become stages for intensive research activity. Every visit to a vent site, even a repeat visit, brings new discoveries, says Cindy Van Dover, director of Duke University's Marine Laboratory in Beaufort, N.C.

"Some places are so popular that you get ships [above them] stacked up on top of one another," notes Van Dover. If researchers aren't careful, she says, they'll interfere with each other's work or harm the vent ecosystems.

Such concerns triggered scientists to issue, earlier this year, a code of conduct for hydrothermal-vent research. In July, underwater volcanologist Colin Devey of the University of Kiel in Germany described the code at the Euroscience Open Forum in Munich. His university is the current home of InterRidge, the loosely affiliated group of hydrothermal-vent researchers that developed the code.

Explains Devey, "On a highway with only two vehicles, having rules of the road is fairly unimportant. But every time another vehicle comes along, it becomes increasingly important to know such things as which side of the road to drive on and who has the right of way." With scientific and mining-exploration visits to vent sites increasing, he says, "we realized we needed rules to deal with that traffic."

The new code also serves as a self-policing protocol for investigators who conduct their research largely out of sight, usually kilometers below the sea's surface.

Hot spots

The geologically active sites where these scientists work represent two extremes of the global tectonic system. The best characterized of these hydrothermal vents occur at various intervals along a tectonic plate's new-forming edge, known as a spreading zone. Earth's mid-ocean ridge is one near-continuous zone of spreading seafloor.

photo

NIGHT LIFE. These stalked barnacles (Vulcanolepas osheai) thrive at a vent site in the Lau Basin, between Fiji and Samoa, that's so deep that it's always pitch black there. The site is part of what biologist Charles Fisher describes as "the center of diversity for barnacles."

C. Fisher/Ridge 2000 Program

As two plates pull apart, breaches occasionally permit magma to break through the ridge's crest, where the molten rock heats zones of rock and water (SN: 4/1/06, p. 202). A spreading zone can be considered a "linear volcano" with vent holes occurring at various points along its meandering crest, explains Edward T. Baker, an oceanographer at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Seattle lab.

Last December, Baker and his colleagues traveled to a previously uncharted 400-km span of the mid-ocean ridge in the Pacific, just north of the Galápagos Islands. Their sophisticated equipment turned up direct evidence of three new hydrothermal vents in that spreading zone and indirect evidence—hydrothermal plumes—of several more.

On the opposite end of a tectonic plate from its spreading zone may be a subduction zone, a span where two plates collide and one plate is forced beneath the other. Weak spots emerge near the edge of the disappearing plate, permitting magma to punch through and form conventional, conical volcanoes that happen to be underwater. These vulnerable areas are known as back-arc basins (SN: 6/10/06, p. 365).

Both types of hydrothermal vents—at seafloor ridges and at back arcs—spew hot water that's oxygen-deprived and metal-rich, and they host a wide variety of exotic marine life. Researchers marvel at the diversity of unusual animals populating these dark and seemingly inhospitable zones, some of the organisms surviving near water as hot as molten lead. Because animals at these sites derive their energy solely from the microbial transformation of chemicals spewed by the geological activity, their ecosystems are referred to as chemosynthetic.

In the decade after the first hydrothermal vents were discovered in 1977, notes Baker, the high costs of visiting such areas limited scientists' choices. Researchers tended to go to ridge sites where they were virtually guaranteed to find vents, so they focused on similar sites and found similar things.

Expeditions gradually began taking more gambles, and over the past decade, they've explored a greater variety of locales, including sites in the Arctic Ocean (SN: 4/1/06, p. 202). "What we've found is that there's never been an occasion where we didn't find evidence of venting within any 200-km section of [the] mid-ocean ridge," notes Christopher R. German of the Woods Hole (Mass.) Oceanographic Institution.

Vents often differ dramatically from each other in chemical and geological characteristics. However, even vents that are physically similar can host distinctly different communities of animals.

"The classic example" of a vent creature, German notes, "is those giant tube worms, perhaps 8 feet [2.4 meters] long. But you don't find those outside the Pacific." First identified on the Galápagos section of the ridge, these worms don't inhabit the northeastern Pacific. There, smaller tube worms congregate.

Go to the North Atlantic, and the tube worms are replaced by vent communities dominated by shrimp a couple inches long and mussels, German says. Move to vents in the Indian Ocean for an intermediate fauna. Atlantic-type shrimp are common there, as are barnacles, snails, and a host of animals typically found at West Pacific vents.

As part of a 10-year international census of marine life, German and others have begun mapping what they call the "biogeography of chemosynthetic ecosystems."

Light-touch science

Fifteen or so years ago, studying hydrothermal-vent denizens was crude: "To collect something, people used to simply drag dredges from ships through vent fields," Baker says. Over time, researchers have become gentler and more selective. Today, they first observe animals from submersibles or in pictures taken by computer-operated, torpedolike devices armed with sophisticated sensors and cameras. Biologists then perform "precision sampling" of a few critters of special interest, Van Dover says.

photo

INFECTED. This Fiji mussel's flesh, which in a healthy animal (Bathymodiolus brevior) is beige, has been blackened by an advanced fungal infection. Researchers are concerned because they may have spread this disease to mussels at another vent site.

Van Dover

Using this process, scientists are finding 100 new species each year, Van Dover estimates.

The new code of conduct makes an explicit commitment to such minimally invasive sampling. The InterRidge document, endorsed by organizations representing 2,000 vent researchers, pledges to avoid engaging in research activities that "will have deleterious impacts on the sustainability" of vent populations, lead to long or significant alteration—even in just appearance—of vent sites, or take vent materials "not essential" to research.

The code also prohibits transplanting materials, such as tube worms and other animals, between vents. The researchers want to avoid introducing species that might establish themselves and alter a native vent ecosystem, German explains.

A year ago, Van Dover's experience during a biogeography study reinforced concerns over such transplants. She and her colleagues had collected vent shellfish at back-arc vents in the Fiji Basin. At least 60 percent of the mussels (Bathymodiolus brevior) there had curious brown or black spots. A few days later, the researchers sampled mussels at back-arc vents in the nearby Lau Basin.

Once home, Van Dover examined the flesh of the Fiji Basin mussels more closely and discovered that their spots were caused by a fungal infection. In some specimens, she says, "there was more fungus than mussel."

Because her team didn't wash out the collection boxes between sites, Van Dover worries that her team may have transferred fungus spores from infected mussels of the Fuji Basin to healthy shellfish in the Lau Basin.

"I won't go back out again without carrying bottles of bleach to do washdowns," Van Dover says.

Species can spread via other means. Van Dover notes that the submersibles used to survey vent sites contain ballast water that's jettisoned as the vehicles surface. Animals or microbes can be sucked in with the ballast water at one site and released elsewhere.

Antje Boetius of the Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology in Bremen, Germany, finds less reason for concern about transplanting fungi or other microbes. Because all oceans are connected, she notes, "an educated guess would be that we cannot introduce microbes…to new sites because they're already there." Nevertheless, she adds, "our code of conduct will be so strict that, in theory, it would prevent even this—transporting microbes from one place to another."

Commercial appeal

The InterRidge code was drafted and adopted by scientists conducting basic research. However, vent sites also receive attention from investigators engaged in applied research for commercial firms, principally companies interested in mining the copper, gold, silver, zinc, and lead that bubble up at vents and then lie exposed on the ocean floor.

"I don't expect the mining community is terribly aware of the code of conduct for scientists," says Toronto-based consulting geologist Steven D. Scott. However, he notes that 5 years ago, the International Marine Minerals Society, based in Honolulu, adopted its own code for environmental management of marine mining.

That code calls for mining companies to "apply best practical procedures" for environmental and resource protection, "consider environmental implications" through all stages of mining starting with exploration, return unused extracted materials to the seabed "in a manner that will facilitate future sustainable use of the area," and conduct environmental studies as a basis for evaluating risks and responsible postproduction-cleanup strategies.

In other words, Scott argues, the mining community is also trying to exhibit responsible environmental stewardship of vent resources. At the Euroscience Open Forum, he conceded that ocean mining has the potential to adversely affect vent ecosystems. However, he says, "it should present far less of a problem than mining on land."

With vent water carrying metals directly from Earth's mantle, 2 million tons of ore from ocean sites should yield as much copper as 80 million tons of material mined on land, according to his company's recent study in waters off Papua New Guinea, reports David J. Heydon, chief executive officer of Nautilus Minerals in Vancouver, British Columbia. Nautilus Minerals is one of two companies formed so far to mine ocean-bottom minerals.

Mining companies are focusing on extinct-vent sites to avoid the challenges of superheated water and molten rock. Ecosystems at these thermally extinct vents may be less novel than those dominated by the short-lived, quick-growing animals at active vents (SN: 7/14/01, p. 21).

On the other hand, Van Dover points out, there's evidence suggesting that tube worms have lived for 100 years at some cold sites. Ecologically, she says, killing them during mining might be equivalent to cutting down an old-growth forest. Indeed, she argues, animals at these sites "may turn out to be more sensitive than those at [still-hot] vents. We don't yet know."

Cradles of life?

Vent sites are unstable. Every 10 to 100 years, a new flow of lava kills off life and repaves the surrounding ocean bottom. Yet only days later, animals begin recolonizing a vent. That finding, which is less than 2 decades old, has established the "simple but profound truth," Baker says, that "volcanoes and the presence of water are sufficient [to support] life."

photo

FINE CHEMICAL DINING. Nestled in a bed of mussels are big, hairy, light-colored snails (Alviniconcha hessleri) and their darker cousins (Ifremeri nautilei). All these western Pacific–vent animals host bacteria that nurture the shellfish by filtering compounds from hydrothermal plumes and passing the chemicals on to the mollusks.

C. Fisher/Ridge 2000 Program

Direct ancestors of vent bacteria "may extend back 4 billion years," he notes. Studying current generations of these microbes may therefore offer clues to life's origins (SN: 1/9/99, p. 24) and the possibility that geologic activity has similarly fostered life elsewhere "in and beyond our own solar system," Baker says.

Although large fauna such as tube worms (SN: 4/15/06, p. 228) and hairy blond crabs (SN: 4/1/06, p. 205) garner most of the public attention given to deep-sea vents, Boetius points out that the biggest share of undiscovered species there are microbial. As part of the International Census of Marine Microbes, under way through 2010, she hopes to resolve whether bacteria at vent sites are novel or just the same marine species—perhaps in different proportions—that occur elsewhere in the ocean.

However, some scientists challenge the ethics of conducting these and other studies, charging that they all pose risks to life at vent sites.

For instance, in a Jan. 13, 2005, letter to Nature, former vent scientist Magnus Johnson of the University of Hull in Scarborough, England, cited a 1977 report that vent shrimp were probably blinded by floodlights on exploratory submarines (SN: 4/3/99, p. 219). "The Worldwide Fund for Nature has recognized that one of the greatest threats to hydrothermal vents comes from 'uncoordinated and unregulated' research," Johnson pointed out.

Charles Fisher of Pennsylvania State University in University Park, who has just returned from a South Pacific research cruise, concedes that scientists and their equipment are probably the greatest threats to deep sites—but only because few other people get down there. However, he argues that scientists aren't inflicting much injury on vent ecosystems. Moreover, he and others note that the new code of conduct is intended to limit even that small potential for researchers' doing harm.

********

Letters:

This article barely scratches the surface of the problem. What is stopping someone from gene splicing the disease of choice onto heat-loving bacterium? Something that can live near the 600°F of melting lead will certainly survive the standard hospital-sterilization process.

D.J. Kava
Beaumont, Texas

The statement "2 tons of ore from ocean sites should yield as much copper as 80 million tons of material mined on land" can't be correct. That's 40 million to 1. No one mines that kind of ore.

Terrence Kerwin
Silverton, Colo.

The statement should have been that 2 million tons of ocean ore would yield that much copper.—J. Raloff

References:

Herring, P.J., E. Gaten, and P.M.J. Shelton. 1999. Are vent shrimps blinded by science? Nature 398(March 11):116. Abstract.

InterRidge Statement of Commitment to Responsible Research Practices at Deep-Sea Hydrothermal Vents. Available at http://interridge.org/.

International Marine Minerals Society. 2001. Code for Environmental Management of Marine Mining. Available at http://www.immsoc.org/IMMS_code.htm.

Johnson, M. 2005. Oceans need protection from scientists too. Nature 433(Jan. 13):105. Abstract.

Van Dover, C.L., C.R. German, et al. 2002. Evolution and biogeography of deep-sea vent and seep invertebrates. Science 295(Feb. 15):1253–1257. Abstract.

Van Dover, C.L., et al. 2001. Biogeography and ecological setting of Indian Ocean hydrothermal vents. Science 294(Oct. 26):818–823. Abstract.

Further Readings:

Gramling, C. 2006. Uncharted territory. Science News 169(April 1):202–204. Available at Science News.

Milius, S. 2006. Into hot water: Lab test shows that worms seek heat. Science News 169(April 15):228. Available at Science News.

______. 2006. Hairy crab lounges deep in the Pacific. Science News 169(April 1):205. Available at Science News.

______. 1999. Scientists' lights blind deep-sea shrimp. Science News 155(April 3):219.

Morgan, K. 2003. A rocky start. Science News 163(April 26):264-265. Available at Science News.

Pedrós-Alió, C. 2006. Marine microbial diversity: Can it be determined? Trends in Microbiology 14(June):257–263. Abstract.

Perkins, S. 2006. Deep-sea action. Science News 169(June 10):365. Available at Science News.

______. 2003. Northern vents: Arctic shows surprising hydrothermal activity. Science News 163(Jan. 18):37. Available at Science News.

______. 2002. Famed undersea vent may be lost. Science News 161(June 15):382. Available at Science News.

______. 2001. New type of hydrothermal vent looms large. Science News 160(July 14):21. Available at Science News.

______. 2000. Cooking up a key chemical of life. Science News 158(Sept. 9):175. Available at Science News.

Simpson, S. 1999. Life's first scalding steps. Science News 155(Jan. 9):24–26. Available at Science News.

Sogin, M.L., et al. 2006. Microbial diversity in the deep sea and the underexplored "rare biosphere." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103(Aug. 8):12115–12120. Abstract.

Sources:

Edward T. Baker
Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
7600 Sand Point Way, NE
Seattle, WA 98115-6349

Antje Boetius
Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology
Celsiusstraße 1
28359 Bremen
Germany

Census of Marine Life
Consortium for Oceanographic Research and Education (CORE)
12021 New York Avenue, NW, Ste. 420
Washington, DC 20005

Colin W. Devey
Leibniz-Institute für Meereswissenschaften(IFM-GEOMAR)
Gebäude Ostufer
Wischhofstraße 1-3
D-24148 Kiel
Germany

Charles Fisher
208 Mueller Laboratory
Pennsylvania State University
University Park, PA 16802

Christopher R. German
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
Mail Stop 24, G&G
Woods Hole, MA 02543

David J. Heydon
Nautilis Minerals
Suite 920
475 West Georgia Street
Vancouver, BC V6B 4M9
Canada

Intenational Census of Marine Microbes
Josephine Bay Paul Center
7 MBL Street
Woods Hole, MA 02543

International Marine Minerals Society
Administrative Office
1000 Pope Road, 303
Honolulu, HI 96822

Magnus Johnson
Scarborough Centre for Coastal Studies
University of Hull
Filey Road
Scarborough YO11 3AZ
United Kingdom

Steven D. Scott
Department of Geology
University of Toronto
Toronto, ON M5S 3B1
Canada

Cindy Lee Van Dover
Duke University Marine Laboratory
Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences
135 Marine Lab Road
Beaufort, NC 28516


From Science News, Volume 170, No. 15, October 7, 2006, p. 232.